IP Journal of Otorhinolaryngology and Allied Science

Print ISSN: 2582-4147

Online ISSN: 2582-421X

CODEN : IJOABK

IP Journal of Otorhinolaryngology and Allied Science (JOAS) open access, peer-reviewed quarterly journal publishing since 2018 and is published under the Khyati Education and Research Foundation (KERF), is registered as a non-profit society (under the society registration act, 1860), Government of India with the vision of various accredited vocational courses in healthcare, education, paramedical, yoga, publication, teaching and research activity, with the aim of faster and better dissemination of knowledge, we will be publishing the article more...

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article statistics

Viewed: 299

PDF Downloaded: 1080


Get Permission Makkar: Mindfulness and its impact in cancer patients- Evidence based medicine


Introduction

Mindfulness is defined as "paying attention in a specific way: on purpose, in the present moment, and without judgment" according to Kabat and Zinn.1 The idea that emotions play a major role in cancer extends from classical times. Galen, an ancient Greek physician, discovered that despondent women were more susceptible to breast cancer.2 The 18th and 19th century medical literature consistently related cancer to loss and depressive symptoms.

The definition of transpersonal psychology is "the study of humanity's highest potential and the recognition, comprehension, and actualization of unitive, spiritual, and transcendent experiences."3 It "includes the individual and cosmic aspects of life, heart, mind, and spirit, human and nonhuman, interbeing and ecological"; it is a psychology that acknowledges our divine position in space and time.4

Mindfulness enables meditators to have better clarity and insight and to tap the inner world and healing power necessary to nurture well-being on numerous levels of creation. Practitioners of mindfulness meditation become active participants in their own rehabilitation as they learn to employ their mental, physical, and spiritual aspects of a person's existence impact their recuperation journey.

Purpose of the article

This study explored how the MBSR program functioned as a holistic remedy for older individuals and how it affected various aspects of their lives. It cast good perspective on how MBSR can be used as an adjunctive intervention and nonpharmacological treatment for older adults in order to help them cope with the various changes they encounter at this age. This study also identified specific ways in which the MBSR program must be modified to meet the unique requirements of older individuals. This study provided an in-depth comprehension, within the field of transpersonal psychology, of how mindfulness meditation promoted profound change in these older individuals and how mindfulness practice itself facilitated spiritual transformation.

Personal interest

My anecdotal evidence with mindfulness practices and the MBSR program kindled my interest in this topic. I was profoundly influenced by mindfulness and the practices because, in my daily practice, the majority of orthopedic patients, including orthopedic oncology patients, were distressed due to their diagnosis and associated stigma, whereas a select few were serene, cheerful, and accepted life as it is. It piqued my interest, so I inquired in-depth about their personal practices. I observed that the majority of peaceful patients held a firm belief in some spiritual form or another, based on their religion. This exemplifies mindfulness. This prompted me to conduct a literature review and write this article so that other patients can benefit from evidence-based practices.

Why did we choose studies involving cancer patients for this study?

Cancer continues a significant global public health concern, with over 10 million deaths projected by 2020.5 By 2030, an incremental million fatalities annually will be attributed to cancer, the vast majority of which will occur in low- and middle-income regions.6 Most patients in low-resource situations don't seek medical attention until their condition has progressed to the point where there are no effective treatments left and they have severe palliative care needs.

Cancer leads to an array of discomforting and difficult-to-manage symptoms and worries that cut deeply into patient and family well-being.7 These symptoms and worries span the physical, social, psychological, and spiritual realms, and so have far-reaching effects on the patient's quality of life and level of suffering. Psychological symptoms include anxiety, depression/depressive symptoms (such as low mood, sadness), irritability, and concern. Lack of serenity and spiritual suffering are examples of prevalent spiritual symptoms, while examples of social problems include a lack of knowledge, social isolation, and psychological distress.8

What is mindfulness and how to practice it?

One of the principal main groups of meditation practices is mindfulness.9 Mindfulness derives from the Pali and Sanskrit words sati and smirti, which mean consciousness, focus, and recollection. The term "mindfulness" has been called the "heart of Buddhist meditation" and it encompasses two distinct concepts: (a) mindful awareness, which is a "abiding presence or awareness," a "deep knowing" that appears as freedom of mind (e.g., liberation from reflexive conditioning and delusion); and (b) mindful practice, which is the "systematic practice of consciously attending in an open, compassionate, and discerning way.”10

Acceptance, nonjudgment, forbearance, nonstriving, faith, open mindedness, letting go, tenderness, benevolence, empathy, gratitude, and lovingkindness are the 12 attitudes involved in mindfulness.11

Consequently, a number of programs combining mindfulness meditation and psychological techniques have been devised in order to promote emotional and physical health. These initiatives are not rooted in any cultural or religious tradition, enabling for the implementation of mindfulness training in mental health and clinical settings.12

Mindfulness facilitates the process of mental formation.13 Individuals discover how to be present and completely aware of the present situation, with receptivity and understanding, without attempting to retreat into feelings about the past or tomorrow that are simply images of consciousness.

Mindfulness on the present moment cultivates one's capacity to break free of automatic mental and emotional responses to one's surroundings and inner thoughts. It enables the practitioner to learn to differentiate between how things appear to the senses and how they are conceptualized and projected in the mind. This allows the practitioner to better understand and evaluate sensory perception and inner mental states. Every emotion or thought is merely noted, rather than reflexively reacting to.

Aims of the Study

This study aims to answer the following research question: How does the Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) program affect cancer patients' mental health, physical health, neuropsychological performance, and spirituality? What does the literature say about the use of the practice as an adjuvant treatment in individuals diagnosed with any malignancy, particularly bone tumors?

Materials and Methods

This study utilized a mixed-method and integral inquiry approach, combining quantitative and qualitative methods of data collection and analysis in order to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the effects and lived experience of the MBSR program among older adults.14, 15

We included published studies in our article, but excluded the thesis and ongoing research due to lack of evidence. We used "many eyes" (perspectives), "many brains" (approaches to analyzing and interpreting data), and "many mouths" technique for analysis of the results of this study.(strategies for conveying and discussing findings.15

We analyzed the studies regarding the experience of patients after eight weeks of the MBSR program, the initial assessment of anxiety and depression due to the diagnosis and treatment of cancer, and the final assessment after eight weeks of the MBSR program.

Consequently, we analyzed both the subjective and objective evaluations of these practices.

Discussion

Several qualitative investigations have found a correlation between one's spiritual or religious beliefs and practices and their ability to cope positively with cancer;16, 17, 18

According to studies, cancer survivors frequently have spiritual concerns and expect their oncology clinicians to address their spiritual requirements;.19 However, most physicians do not discuss spiritual matters with patients.19, 20 With the introduction of integrative care, such as mind–body therapeutic practices in oncology, this framework must be reexamined. In recent years, research has demonstrated that cancer survivors with life-threatening ailments have experienced positive psychological changes.21

Patients may have increased levels of despair and anxiety following a diagnosis of a serious illness like cancer. Depressive symptoms and syndromes are more common in people with greater physical impairment and suffering due to cancer, and affect 20–25% of cancer patients. Other malady sequelae, such as cancer-related post-surgery malaise due to chemotherapy or radiotherapy, and disturbed sleep, have also been extensively documented.

Among these psychosocial interventions, mindfulness meditation has demonstrated some effectiveness in fostering stress relief and alleviating psychological tension. The mindfulness refers to a "particular method of paying attention" or "moment-to-moment awareness" in which the subject maintains nonjudgmental and accepting of the various feelings, emotions, and perceptions that span his or her mind. Similarly, it has been defined as the nonjudgmental observation of the continuous flow of internal and external stimuli as they arise.

The typical length of a single weekly session is two and a half hours, and there is a supplementary all-day session per course on a weekend day. Each gathering explores specific exercises and concepts within the paradigm of mindfulness. These involve various types of mindfulness meditation, mindful awareness during yoga postures, and mindfulness in demanding circumstances and interpersonal relationships. Participants adhere to daily 45-minute homework assignments consisting primarily of meditation practice, mindful yoga, and the application of mindfulness to real-world situations, as the cultivation of mindfulness is dependent on regular and repeated practice.

Neurobiological alterations in brain structure and function that appear to be associated to mindfulness practice have been documented by neuroimaging22, 23 In addition, meditative practices manifest an increase activity in the anterior cingulate cortex, a brain region associated with the self-regulation of concentration.24

Cortisol, the principal stress hormone produced by the adrenal glands, is known to have immunosuppressive effects and is mainly culpable for the stress-induced suppression of immune function.25, 26, Its hypersecretion can also cause depression.27 In addition, breast cancer patients have been found to have increased cortisol levels both prior to and after treatment.28 Seventy-five percent of metastatic breast and ovarian cancer patients have anomalous cortisol secretion trends, according to. In a group of women with metastatic breast cancer, the slope of the rate of change of cortisol levels throughout the day was correlated with life expectancy, with women who exhibited less fluctuation in cortisol levels, depicted as a flatter slope, enduring premature demise.29

MBSR and related stress disorders in oncology

The purpose of the randomized controlled trial conducted by Carlson et al' was to evaluate the effects of participation in an MBSR program on symptoms of anxiety.30 The presence of tension and mood disturbances in cancer outpatients. As determined by the Symptoms of Stress Inventory" "'I and Profile of Moor States (POMS)'"'I Patients' fears decreased significantly pre- and post-intervention, indicating less mood perturbation and fewer stress-related symptoms. Minimal changes occurred in the wait-list control participant during this time period. More Home practice was associated with reductions in tension and total mood disturbance. Bette attendance was also associated with greater declines in stress symptoms, possibly because participants benefited from the presence of others who served as role models for effective coping and stress-reduction techniques "

MBSR and immune function in cancer patient

Meditation has been linked to immunological effects.' These findings pertain to the field of psychoimmunology. We anticipate that interventions that modify the stress response will result in characteristic and corresponding changes in psychoimmunology functioning.

The 2003 study by Carlson and co-authors "analyzed the relationship between a mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) program and quality of life in early-stage breast and prostate cancer patients, mood conditions, a correlation between stress symptoms, lymphocyte counts, and cytokine production.

Table 1

Regarding disorders or areas of concern of participants, groups may be varied or similar

Author

Year

Mean age of patients

Type of cancer

Type and duration of mindfulness training

Intervention

What was measured

Outcome

Herbert et al

2001

50

Breast

15 weeks of mindfulness

Intervention The Nutrition Education Program (NEP), which was primarily group-based and overseen by a nutritionist, was compared to the Stress Reduction Clinic Program (SRC) and Usual Supportive Care (USC) (UC).

body mass; 7DDR-dietary fat, complex carbohydrates, fiber

The dietary intervention ameliorated the weight changes i.e. weight gain

Monti et al

2005

53.6

Breast, gynecologic, hematologic, neurologic, rectal, o

Eight week of MBAT 2 hr session and 2 sessions per week

MBAT means mindfulness based art therapy

Comparison was made between the patients being offered MBAT and those on the wait list for the treatment were considered controls.

Both before and after the intervention (at weeks 0 and 8 and 16), symptoms of psychological distress and stress-related physical problems were measured.

using

SCL-90-R, or the Revised Symptoms Checklist. Nine symptom dimensions and a summary score (Global Severity Index) are evaluated across the SCL-90-R's 90 items (GSI). The GSI is the most accurate measure of the ongoing distress.

PSY: distress, QOL (SCL-90-R, SF- 36 mental health component), PHY: SF-36 physical health components

Distress symptoms (as judged by the Symptoms Checklist-90-Revised) decreased significantly in the MBAT group, and important aspects of health-related quality of life improved significantly, as relative to the controls population (as measured by the Medical Outcomes Study Short-Form Health Survey).

Shapiro et al

2003

57

Breast

Within two-year post-treatment

Not specified 6 weeks (2-h sessions),

one 6-h silent retreat

PSY: sleep latency, quality of sleep, feelings upon awakening, total sleep; QOL, psychological distress (POMS), sense of control (SCI), anxiety (STATE), depression (BDI), sense of coherence (SOC), worry (PENN)

Speca et al

2000

50.8

Breast, ovarian, prostate, NHL, melanoma, endometrial, colon, cervical, other

7-week MBSR program

(90 min per session)

PSY: mood (POMS), stress (SOSI mental health component), PHY: SOSI physical health components

Carlson et al

2004

54.5

Breast prostate

8-week MBSR program (90 min/session); 3-h silent retreat at week 6/7

The program had three paramount aspects:: theoretical content on mindfulness, relaxation, meditation, yoga, and the body–mind link, experiential training of meditation and yoga during group sessions and home-based practice, and group process focusing on solving problems related to barriers to successful practice, practical mindfulness applications, and supportive collaboration.

The levels of cortisol and melatonin in saliva were measured utilizing solid-phase ELISAs while DHEAS was measured based on serum levels.

PHY: cortisol, melatonin, DHEAS

Approximately 40% of the sample exhibited aberrant cortisol secretion patterns both pre- and post-intervention; however, within this group, trends switched from "inverted-V-shaped" to "V-shaped" secretion. There were no aggregate changes in DHEAS or melatonin, but insignificant alterations in DHEAS patterns were consistent with healthier profiles in both men and women.

Carlson et al

2005

54

Breast, prostate, ovarian NHL

Not specified 8-week MBSR program (90 min/session); 3-h silent retreat at week 6

PSY: sleep (PSQI), stress (SOSI mental health components), mood and fatigue (POMS) PHY: SOSI physical health components

Garland et al

2007

52

Prostate, colorectal, lung, ear/ nose/throat, brain, skin, lymphatic, other

specified 8-week MBSR program (90 min/session); 3-h silent retreat at week 6/

PSY: post-traumatic growth (PTGIR); spirituality (FACIT-Sp); stress (SOSI mental health components), mood (POMS) PHY: SOSI physical health component

Overall quality of life as measured by the European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire (EORTC QL(C30) improved significantly.31 Although there were no significant changes in the total number of lymphocytes or cell subsets, the changes in the immune profiles of these patients were indicative of a shift away from a depressive pattern and toward one more indicative of robust immune function. This was also the first study to demonstrate alterations in cancer-related cytokine production as a result of a program.

MBSR and sleep disturbance

Shapiro and colleagues also investigated the efficacy of an MBSR intervention for breast cancer patients, focusing on the impacts of sleep complaints. The authors hypothesized that mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) would aid in reducing psychological distress. Increase the capacity to monitor negative thoughts and, as a result, reduce sleep disturbance. The analyses of the data revealed that participation in the MBSR programme led to a significant improvement in daily diary sleep quality measurements but not in sleep efficacy. Participants who reported more mindfulness practice performed significantly better on the sleep quality indicator most strongly associated with distress. The authors concluded that MBSR appears to be a promising intervention for enhancing the sleep quality of breast cancer patients with stress-related sleep complaints.32, 33

MBSR and the hormonal connection

In a 1995 study, Massion and colleagues tested the hypothesis that frequent mindfulness meditation practice is associated with higher physiological levels of the pineal hormone melatonin. Melatonin may be associated with a variety of biological functions that are essential for maintaining health and preventing disease, such as breast and prostate cancer. The results of the study indicated that regular meditation had an effect on the women who participated. These results supported the authors' hypothesis that meditation practice is associated with increased melatonin levels.34

Similarly, healthy regular meditators produced higher levels of melatonin after a nocturnal meditation session than on a control night when they did not practice meditation.

Conclusion

For me, mindfulness meditation is a marvelous tool for gaining access to my true self and a technique that enables me to be conscious, to embrace life events with serenity, to face anguish with resilience and self belief, to connect with my divinity, to be in the universe and connect with the others, and to find meaning in every moment of my life. Mindfulness is a way of Being and a means of being present.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

M Staff JK Zinn Jon Kabat-Zinn: Defining Mindfulness2017https://www.mindful.org/jon-kabat-zinn-defining-mindfulness/

2 

CB Bahnson Stress and cancer: the state of the artPsychosomatics1980211297581

3 

DH Lajoie SI Shapiro On defining transpersonal psychologyPsychologia: An Int J Psychol Orient1992352638

4 

M Caplan G Hartelius MA Rardin Contemporary viewpoints on transpersonal psychology.J Transpersonal Psychol200335214362

5 

J Ferlay Cancer statistics for the year 2020: An overviewInt J Cancer2021149477889

6 

W Ngwa Cancer in sub-Saharan Africa: a Lancet Oncology CommissionLancet Oncol2022236251312

7 

SCCM Teunissen W Wesker C Kruitwagen HCJM De Haes EE Voest A De Graeff Symptom Prevalence in Patients with Incurable Cancer: A Systematic ReviewJ Pain Symptom Manag200734194104

8 

MHJ Van Den Beuken Van Everdingen LMJ Hochstenbach EAJ Joosten VCG Tjan-Heijnen DJA Janssen Update on Prevalence of Pain in Patients With Cancer: Systematic Review and Meta-AnalysisJ Pain Symptom Manag2016516107090

9 

D Goleman The Experience of Touch: Research Points to a Critical RoleScience1988https://www.nytimes.com/1988/02/02/science/the-experience-of-touch-research-points-to-a-critical-role.html

10 

BSL Khong Expanding the Understanding of Mindfulness: Seeing the Tree and the ForestHumanistic Psychologist200937211736

11 

SL Shapiro GE Schwartz G Bonner Effects of mindfulness-based stress reduction on medical and premedical studentsJ Behav Med199821658191

12 

A Olendzki Mindfulness and MeditationSpringer20093744

13 

V N Thera F Edition Abhidhamma studiesBuddhist explorations of Consciousness1965

14 

JW Creswell W Zhang The application of mixed methods designs to trauma researchJ Trauma Stress202322661221

15 

W Braud R Anderson Transpersonal Research Methods for the Social SciencesSAGE Publications1998321

16 

KT Ashing-Giwa Understanding the breast cancer experience of women: A qualitative study of African American, Asian American, Latina and Caucasian cancer survivorsPsycho Oncol200413640828

17 

M Sweet LK Michaelsen Team-Based Learning in the Social Sciences and Humanities: Group Work that Works to Generate Critical Thinking and EngagementStylus Publishing, LLC2012https://www.researchgate.net/publication/331843105_Team-Based_Learning_in_the_Social_Sciences_and_Humanities_Group_Work_that_Works_to_Generate_Critical_Thinking_and_Engagement

18 

V Nejati Principles of Cognitive Rehabilitation1stElsevier202368

19 

DM Balboni DJ Peteet Spirituality and Religion Within the Culture of Medicine: From Evidence to PracticeOxford University Press2017https://academic.oup.com/book/24624

20 

O Çekirdekci N Kark G Özlem Handbook of Research on Interdisciplinary Perspectives on the Threats and Impacts of PandemicsIGI Global2021556

22 

SW Lazar Meditation experience is associated with increased cortical thicknessNeuroreport2005161718937

23 

D Richard K Zinn Alterations in Brain and Immune Function Produced by Mindfulness MeditationPsychosomatic Med202365456470

24 

A Lutz HA Slagter JD Dunne RJ Davidson Attention regulation and monitoring in meditationTrends Cogn Sci20081241639

25 

RW Andersen Y Shirai Discourse Motivations for Some Cognitive Acquisition PrinciplesStud Second Language Acquisition202316213356

26 

S Cohen GM Williamson Stress and infectious disease in humansPsychological Bull19911091524

27 

CR Sikes PE Stokes RC Carson BJ Lasley Cognitive sequelae of pituitary-adrenal dysregulation in major depressionAm Coli Neuro psychopharm19892571489

28 

GV Der Pompe HJ Duivenvoorden MH Antoni A Visser CJ Heijnen Effectiveness of a short-term group psychotherapy program on endocrine and immune function in breast cancer patients: An exploratory studyJ Psychosomatic Res199742545366

29 

SE Sephton RM Sapolsky HC Kraemer D Spiegel Diurnal Cortisol Rhythm as a Predictor of Breast Cancer SurvivalJ National Cancer Inst200092129941000

30 

L E Carlson M Speca P Faris K D Patel One year pre-post intervention follow-up of psychological, immune, endocrine and blood pressure outcomes of mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) in breast and prostate cancer outpatientsBrain, Behavior, and Immunity200721810381049

31 

32 

AM Tacón AM Tacón C Ronaghan Mindfulness, Psychosocial Factors, and Breast CancerJ Cancer Pain Symptom Palliation2005114553

33 

SL Shapiro The integration of mindfulness and psychologyJ Clin Psychol200965655560

34 

D Nehra S Nehra R Dogra Positive Psychological Functioning with Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) ProgramBiopsychosocial Issues Positive Health2023328https://www.researchgate.net/publication/252627080_Positive_Psychological_Functioning_with_Mindfulness_Based_Stress_Reduction_MBSR_Program



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

Article type

Review Article


Article page

3-11


Authors Details

Dheeraj Makkar


Article History

Received : 27-04-2023

Accepted : 06-05-2023


Article Metrics


View Article As

 


Downlaod Files